Disturbia, fiction, family, friends, and everything else between the lions.
Would you?
Published on March 9, 2006 By Tova7 In Misc

I picked up an old Sci-Fi book at the library a few days ago.

 

One of the characters in the book is dying with a “terminal illness.”

 

Her husband is standing outside the door of the hospital room and hears her conversing with someone inside.

 

That “someone” is offering her the opportunity to get well, be totally healed.  The catch is, someone must die in her place.  She is promised it will not be someone she knows.

 

She refuses, and her husband barges in to find ~gasp~ no one there.  Since its after hours he hides in the closet when a nurse comes in to check her.  As he watches through a crack in the door, he mumbles something like, “Whoever you are, she would not take your bargain, but I WILL.”

 

A disembodied voice says, “So be it.”

 

That’s as far as I read before falling to sleep.

 

But this morning when I woke its on my mind.  Would I be able to do the same thing?  If say, my child or husband lay dying of a painful disease, could I sacrifice another life for theirs?

 

Would you?


Comments
on Mar 09, 2006
Tough question.

As much as I love my wife, as much as she completes who and what I am, I don't think I could go through with that. Next to suicide, it strikes me as the second most selfish action you could take. In effect, you're saying "My loved one's life is worth more than your loved one's life."

While I can understand that grief and desperation can drive you to do things that you normally wouldn't, I don't think I would be able to do that.

Now, killing someone in self-defence, defence of a loved one, in a ware situation, or defence of a helpless/less capable person - that I don't think I would have a problem doing. I've never been placed in that situation, but I've had ample training and preperation for that situation, if the need arises. God grant that it doesn't.
on Mar 09, 2006
My first initial reaction would be YES, do it. I would do anything especially for my babies. If it was in the heat of the moment yes, I would do it.

If I had time to think about it. I don't know. I would love to say I would be as kind as Chaos, but I don't know.

It really is a tough question.

Now, I am intrigued. What is the name of the book?
on Mar 09, 2006
No.  Taking an innocent life would cheapen the life you wanted to save.
on Mar 09, 2006

Next to suicide, it strikes me as the second most selfish action you could take.

Good point.

Do you think it would be literally taking someone's life?

on Mar 09, 2006

My first initial reaction would be YES, do it. I would do anything especially for my babies. If it was in the heat of the moment yes, I would do it.

I am with you on this.

When I first asked myself this question the immediate answer was "YES!"  But then I thought, "come on T you wouldn't pull the wings off a butterfly for a million dollars, but you'd let someone else die in the place of your child?"

OF course I rationalized it.  Soldiers die in my place don't they?  What's the difference?

Now, I am intrigued. What is the name of the book?

It's "The Last Guardian of Everness" by John C. Wright.

Of course I am SURE this decision will come back to bite the character in the butt.  Like maybe the person who ends up dying has a cure for the very disease his wife suffers from.....so he is not just saving her life, he is killing all the people who die from that disease after the "cure" would be found.

Killing someone before their "Due" time (if you believe in that sort of thing) would have a ripple effect wouldn't it...and the ring would just get bigger and bigger.

 

 

on Mar 09, 2006

No. Taking an innocent life would cheapen the life you wanted to save

This makes perfect sense.

But you wouldn't be tempted?  I'd be VERY tempted...in the heat of the moment, watching my son/husband suffer.  Especially since, and I'm being honest, I wouldn't know the person.

Selfish?  Yup yup.  BUt I would still be tempted.

on Mar 09, 2006

But you wouldn't be tempted? I'd be VERY tempted...in the heat of the moment, watching my son/husband suffer. Especially since, and I'm being honest, I wouldn't know the person.

Tempted?  Yes.  But the question was would you.  I think just about anyone would at least mull over the idea.  But, hopefull, most would not do it

Although I am reminded of the law and order episode (based upon an Internet Myth) where the rich guy paid a doctcor to steal a kidney from a healthy man for his dying daughter.  In that episode, the man did not die (he almost did, and it was no thanks to the doctor or the rich man), but the man would have killed for his daughter.

So yes, there are some out there like that.

on Mar 09, 2006
There's another story that is very similar. It goes that a couple gets a visitor who offers them $1 million and all they have to do is press a button. When they ask what the button does, the visitor tells them that someone they have no way of ever knowing, somewhere else in the world will die.

The story goes on for a while as they mull over all the moral problems and finally their greed takes over and they agree to it. He keeps his word, and gets ready to leave. They are really happy and ask him where he is going to go to next. He says that he is on his way to take the button somewhere else in the world, to someone they have no way of ever knowing.

In light of that, I'd be very hesitant to make the deal above, simply because the person in question is liable to go straight and make the offer to some OTHER dying person you don't know the same deal, only this time the target will be you...
on Mar 09, 2006

In light of that, I'd be very hesitant to make the deal above, simply because the person in question is liable to go straight and make the offer to some OTHER dying person you don't know the same deal, only this time the target will be you...

Now that is a really good point, one that would NEVER occur to me.

(Though in this book the "person" said the wife would live a long life, he certainly never promised that to the man!)

on Mar 09, 2006

I would not take the voice on their offer but I would willingly sacrifce mt life in return to the other I care about.
on Mar 09, 2006

He says that he is on his way to take the button somewhere else in the world, to someone they have no way of ever knowing.

Another take on this though is, well, even if you turned down the money....that person is still going off to offer the deal to someone else, and you might just die anyway.

In this situation I guess the only ETHICAL thing to do is kill the person making the offer and keep the million.

on Mar 09, 2006

I would not take the voice on their offer but I would willingly sacrifce mt life in return to the other I care about.

That is noble.

Would the person you are dying for, want to carry that the rest of their lives?

on Mar 09, 2006
Of course I am SURE this decision will come back to bite the character in the butt. Like maybe the person who ends up dying has a cure for the very disease his wife suffers from.....so he is not just saving her life, he is killing all the people who die from that disease after the "cure" would be found.

This reminds me of a B.C. comic that I read, oh... about 12 years or so ago. One of the characters is looking up to the clouds and ranting about (paraphrased) "Where are the artists to paint master pieces, the doctors to cure cancer, etc." It went on for a couple panels in this vein. The answer came in the last panel in a voice from Heaven, "You aborted them."

All of the folks that are destined to do these things are coming down the pike. Do we risk these wonderous things not happening?
on Mar 09, 2006

All of the folks that are destined to do these things are coming down the pike. Do we risk these wonderous things not happening?

That's a pretty profound thought.  And I wonder if someday we will ever know or see (not this side of life obviously) exactly what was wrought with abortion, or not wrought as the case may be.